|
|
Survey POL
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2011-08-31 10:25:37
This is what I did:
I took my japanese SCPH-10000 PS2 and it's harddrive out of the closet, hooked it up and connected to PlayOnline...
Then I answered this:

(Yes I'm not lying and yes I'm an IDIOT for giving them that much money ... -__-;)
People who believe that the PS2 is the reason why they can't rework the game is obviously WRONG.
The reason they didn't rework the game yet is COST. Now that they're willing to buff up the game, an solution for keeping the PS2 while upgrading the PC is obviously possible.
So people just need to be HONEST while answering the survey.
What are you on about?
Adding more terms into the auto translate isn't about cost, it's about certain platforms not having the capability. Same with adding maps, newer HD fonts (Which they've done on certain platforms) and other things that have basically no cost and become impossible.
No-one is expecting a full remake at this point, but if you think removing the PS2 as a platform wouldn't improve certain aspects of the game, then you're sorely mistaken.
Ragnarok.Sekundes
Server: Ragnarok
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4215
By Ragnarok.Sekundes 2011-08-31 10:29:08
This is what I did:
I took my japanese SCPH-10000 PS2 and it's harddrive out of the closet, hooked it up and connected to PlayOnline...
Then I answered this:

(Yes I'm not lying and yes I'm an IDIOT for giving them that much money ... -__-;)
People who believe that the PS2 is the reason why they can't rework the game is obviously WRONG.
The reason they didn't rework the game yet is COST. Now that they're willing to buff up the game, an solution for keeping the PS2 while upgrading the PC is obviously possible.
So people just need to be HONEST while answering the survey.
1million times this! i like how ppl think that dropping ps2 support will make better graphic and all the nice things you ever wanted over night.
Am i the only one seeing that getting rid of a % of your population(the evil ps2 players) to then shoot more money in a 10years game, might not be the best solution to make more money? Removing ps2 support will allow them to do two things.
One, not have to spend dev time on an old crappy system and be required to release another version of the game compatible with old hardware each time there is a version update they must code for one more system. If you don't think this costs money...
Two, memory allocation. They can't add everything to the autotranslate nor can they allow us more than 80 inv while supporting the ps2. They have said it. The ps2 has a limited amount of memory addresses to allocate.
I don't care if they don't revamp the graphics. I just want more inv space primarily. The ps2 prevents this.
[+]
Cerberus.Rayik
Server: Cerberus
Game: FFXI
Posts: 924
By Cerberus.Rayik 2011-08-31 10:31:32
Graphics are fine. More inventory, more new areas/mobs/content.
{Yes, please.}
[+]
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 182
By Shiva.Ashmulder 2011-08-31 10:34:13
Ragnarok.Sekundes said: »This is what I did:
I took my japanese SCPH-10000 PS2 and it's harddrive out of the closet, hooked it up and connected to PlayOnline...
Then I answered this:

(Yes I'm not lying and yes I'm an IDIOT for giving them that much money ... -__-;)
People who believe that the PS2 is the reason why they can't rework the game is obviously WRONG.
The reason they didn't rework the game yet is COST. Now that they're willing to buff up the game, an solution for keeping the PS2 while upgrading the PC is obviously possible.
So people just need to be HONEST while answering the survey.
1million times this! i like how ppl think that dropping ps2 support will make better graphic and all the nice things you ever wanted over night.
Am i the only one seeing that getting rid of a % of your population(the evil ps2 players) to then shoot more money in a 10years game, might not be the best solution to make more money? Removing ps2 support will allow them to do two things.
One, not have to spend dev time on an old crappy system and be required to release another version of the game compatible with old hardware each time there is a version update they must code for one more system. If you don't think this costs money...
Two, memory allocation. They can't add everything to the autotranslate nor can they allow us more than 80 inv while supporting the ps2. They have said it. The ps2 has a limited amount of memory addresses to allocate.
I don't care if they don't revamp the graphics. I just want more inv space primarily. The ps2 prevents this.
I totally see them getting rid of a % of their playerbase(how small it is remains to be seen) just so you can get more inventory space.
Fenrir.Mariane
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1766
By Fenrir.Mariane 2011-08-31 10:34:36
What are you on about?
Adding more terms into the auto translate isn't about cost, it's about certain platforms not having the capability. Same with adding maps, newer HD fonts (Which they've done on certain platforms) and other things that have basically no cost and become impossible.
No-one is expecting a full remake at this point, but if you think removing the PS2 as a platform wouldn't improve certain aspects of the game, then you're sorely mistaken.
Auto translate limitations are also a lame excuse. There's a limit indeed, but the limit is programmable. Square Enix is telling you a half truth on this one.
Here is how it works for japanese players:
We're given an special page on POL viewer where we can download updated dictionaries for the game. Then after we have them on the harddrive we can choose which ones we want loaded:
ATOK dictionaries are edited here:
This is the screen where you "equip" the dictionaries you need:
You can see I have four dictionaries installed and there's still some room left. Now that Tetramaster is gone I just have it's dictionary removed.
US and EU clients have dictionaries too but they're "hard wired" within the updates. No means to "select" what you want out of it.
Quetzalcoatl.Xueye
Server: Quetzalcoatl
Game: FFXI
Posts: 6386
By Quetzalcoatl.Xueye 2011-08-31 10:35:59
If you try and argue that a ten year old system or whatever isn't holding a constantly evolving piece of software back...
Go put Microsoft Word 2010 on a Windows 2000
Fenrir.Mariane
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1766
By Fenrir.Mariane 2011-08-31 10:48:25
Ragnarok.Sekundes said: »Removing ps2 support will allow them to do two things.
One, not have to spend dev time on an old crappy system and be required to release another version of the game compatible with old hardware each time there is a version update they must code for one more system. If you don't think this costs money...
Two, memory allocation. They can't add everything to the autotranslate nor can they allow us more than 80 inv while supporting the ps2. They have said it. The ps2 has a limited amount of memory addresses to allocate.
I don't care if they don't revamp the graphics. I just want more inv space primarily. The ps2 prevents this.
The time+money argument is really the only thing I can agree with you. It indeed means they "waste" development time with the PS2 (lol the PS2 is the original code branch of the game so anythign was first developed on the PS2 then ported to the other versions with conversion tools) so I don't think it's that bad.
The inventory size is another artificial limitation introduced by them and does not really have much to do with memory because the space used by items in the inventory is measured in bytes, not kilobytes or megabytes.
Since they've being so generous with storage I can see them expanding the inv space to 99 soon.
I suspect the limit the engine for this game supports is 255 item slots but then that's me. Another thing they should fix but they never cared to is the XBOX360 issue with crowds. Poor coding on their part, honestly. >_>
[+]
By Datruthuhate 2011-08-31 10:49:49
Just face it people, If your still on a PS2, your a moron for not using today's technology plain & simple. You can buy a used pc for 100.00 & a new one for 300.00 to play this game.
SE wants to improve this game in the future & whoever is believing that the PS2 isn't holding this game back is sadly mistaken becuz not only is it hard drive space its the GPU/CPU of the PS2...its fu~~king old & obselete. So people get your heads out ya *** & stop crying like lil babies for ya mommy *** about a PS2 becuz its pretty pathetic if your still using one, cuz I'd be damed if I was still using a Walkman that played tapes....
The future is here, catch up loser!
Asura.Ina
Server: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 17912
By Asura.Ina 2011-08-31 10:50:17
HDD size is obviously NOT an VALID excuse:

(Top of the picture: Free Space 24448 Megabytes) You are confuseing RAM and disk space. The disk space has never been the issue, I couldn't find an actual number for how much ram the ps2 has but maybe this is related? IDK enough about computers to know if it is for sure or not.
Quote: The maximum transmission speed is 66 MB/sec according the PS2 HDD manual - which is 5400 RPMs. The same speed of a decent laptop drive. In comparison, almost all desktop PCs have hard drives with 7200 RPMs. Some PC hard drives even go up to 10000 RPMs. With that said, 5400 RPMs is fast enough for the PlayStation 2. This site was last updated in 2005 so the comparison to desktop and laptop are way out of date.
Ragnarok.Ashman
Server: Ragnarok
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4252
By Ragnarok.Ashman 2011-08-31 10:51:49
The game will end before then.
<<< Has heard this since year 1......
Fenrir.Mariane
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1766
By Fenrir.Mariane 2011-08-31 10:52:14
Just face it people, If your still on a PS2, your a moron for not using today's technology plain & simple. You can buy a used pc for 100.00 & a new one for 300.00 to play this game.
SE wants to improve this game in the future & whoever is believing that the PS2 isn't holding this game back is sadly mistaken becuz not only is it hard drive space its the GPU/CPU of the PS2...its fu~~king old & obselete. So people get your heads out ya *** & stop crying like lil babies for ya mommy *** about a PS2 becuz its pretty pathetic if your still using one, cuz I'd be damed if I was still using a Walkman that played tapes....
The future is here, catch up loser!
Think a bit before calling people losers... It's a ENORMOUS lack of respect on your part.
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2011-08-31 10:54:51
I didn't find you particularly respectful in your first post either.
[+]
Ragnarok.Ashman
Server: Ragnarok
Game: FFXI
Posts: 4252
By Ragnarok.Ashman 2011-08-31 10:55:00
Think a bit before calling people losers... It's a ENORMOUS lack of respect on your part.
I didn't make it past the first sentence :/
By Darkzeru 2011-08-31 10:56:40
The maximum transmission speed is 66 MB/sec according the PS2 HDD manual - which is 5400 RPMs. The same speed of a decent laptop drive.With that said, 5400 RPMs is fast enough for the PlayStation 2. What's the maximum transmission speed for 360 and ps3?
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 182
By Shiva.Ashmulder 2011-08-31 10:57:32
Just face it people, If your still on a PS2, your a moron for not using today's technology plain & simple. You can buy a used pc for 100.00 & a new one for 300.00 to play this game.
SE wants to improve this game in the future & whoever is believing that the PS2 isn't holding this game back is sadly mistaken becuz not only is it hard drive space its the GPU/CPU of the PS2...its fu~~king old & obselete. So people get your heads out ya *** & stop crying like lil babies for ya mommy *** about a PS2 becuz its pretty pathetic if your still using one, cuz I'd be damed if I was still using a Walkman that played tapes....
The future is here, catch up loser!
Thumbs up for showing all of us your lack of IQ...
Fenrir.Mariane
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1766
By Fenrir.Mariane 2011-08-31 10:58:59
You are confuseing RAM and disk space. The disk space has never been the issue, I couldn't find an actual number for how much ram the ps2 has but maybe this is related? IDK enough about computers to know if it is for sure or not.
I am NOT. I didn't mention. Well the PS2 has 32 MEGABYTES of RAM on the main CPU (Emotion Engine) and TWO MEGABYTES of RAM on the IOP (I/O processor, which control inputs and the harddrive).
I know EXACTLY how a PS2 work because back in the day I worked on a PlayStation repair center. I also know that the PS2 has a transfer rate of EIGHT GIGABYTES per second of data from that PUNY 32MB of RAM to it;s GPU. Which is about twice what a AGP PC of it's time could do ...
Now I also understand we're in 2011 but I know they won't rework the game beyond cosmetic fixes. Also the PS2 hardware is dying out of aging so you don't really need to worry with me and other people using it as in no more than two years most consoles will be probably broken. My console is 11 years old and still works great.
Thank you :)
This site was last updated in 2005 so the comparison to desktop and laptop are way out of date.
Yah ... I don't understand why you're comparing this site with the issue of the PS2 being dropped, almost like if you were disagreeing with me on the first half of your post, then agreeing with me on the second ... /huh
Fenrir.Mariane
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1766
By Fenrir.Mariane 2011-08-31 11:02:05
I didn't find you particularly respectful in your first post either.
How come ? I didn't be unpolite. I just exposed facts I believe to be correct.
I didn't really *want* to go out of my way to insult others. It's counterproductive and causes stress... -__-;
What's the maximum transmission speed for 360 and ps3?
Both use laptop SATA harddrives (I believe they are SATA150) with 5400 RPM.
By Datruthuhate 2011-08-31 11:03:10
Just face it people, If your still on a PS2, your a moron for not using today's technology plain & simple. You can buy a used pc for 100.00 & a new one for 300.00 to play this game.
SE wants to improve this game in the future & whoever is believing that the PS2 isn't holding this game back is sadly mistaken becuz not only is it hard drive space its the GPU/CPU of the PS2...its fu~~king old & obselete. So people get your heads out ya *** & stop crying like lil babies for ya mommy *** about a PS2 becuz its pretty pathetic if your still using one, cuz I'd be damed if I was still using a Walkman that played tapes....
The future is here, catch up loser!
Thumbs up for showing all of us your lack of IQ...
Your a troll go get a life
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2011-08-31 11:03:28
Implying people weren't honest isn't a good way to be polite.
Plenty of people (Me included) Never had XI for the PS2 and therefore have answered this poll completely honestly.
Fenrir.Mariane
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1766
By Fenrir.Mariane 2011-08-31 11:04:51
Implying people weren't honest isn't a good way to be polite.
Plenty of people (Me included) Never had XI for the PS2 and therefore have answered this poll completely honestly.
I asked people to be honest. I didn't imply anything. You're assuming I did.
You see, half of the flamethrowing on this forum comes from such assumptions ... ;)
[+]
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 182
By Shiva.Ashmulder 2011-08-31 11:05:56
Just face it people, If your still on a PS2, your a moron for not using today's technology plain & simple. You can buy a used pc for 100.00 & a new one for 300.00 to play this game.
SE wants to improve this game in the future & whoever is believing that the PS2 isn't holding this game back is sadly mistaken becuz not only is it hard drive space its the GPU/CPU of the PS2...its fu~~king old & obselete. So people get your heads out ya *** & stop crying like lil babies for ya mommy *** about a PS2 becuz its pretty pathetic if your still using one, cuz I'd be damed if I was still using a Walkman that played tapes....
The future is here, catch up loser!
Thumbs up for showing all of us your lack of IQ...
Your a troll go get a life
i though insulting people on a message board denied you the rights to have a life.
Phoenix.Sehachan
Server: Phoenix
Game: FFXI
Posts: 13352
By Phoenix.Sehachan 2011-08-31 11:07:44
I know nothing of how coding or any related stuff works.
Shiny graphics would be cool, but lol obviously that's never gonna happen, that's for FFXIV.
I also think that the main issue is money...BUT if ps2 support is responsible partly or entirely for the lack of additions to the game, then please throw it down the gutter.
[+]
Fenrir.Mariane
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1766
By Fenrir.Mariane 2011-08-31 11:08:11
i though insulting people on a message board denied you the rights to have a life.
Leave Datruthuhate alone as bitting the flame bait will wield you nothing but a ENORMOUS headache... -__-
Server: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 23653
By Shiva.Flionheart 2011-08-31 11:09:00
Implying people weren't honest isn't a good way to be polite.
Plenty of people (Me included) Never had XI for the PS2 and therefore have answered this poll completely honestly.
I asked people to be honest. I didn't imply anything. You're assuming I did.
You see, half of the flamethrowing on this forum comes from such assumptions ... ;)
You went on a huge rant about how the PS2 is awesome, and then told people to be honest.
It's not hard to pull an implication from that. And in general you have a brusque holier than thou attitude to anyone who disagrees with your point of view.
By volkom 2011-08-31 11:09:03
I'd really like to know the percentages of the FFXI population that plays on the different platforms
[+]
By Datruthuhate 2011-08-31 11:11:11
i though insulting people on a message board denied you the rights to have a life.
Leave Datruthuhate alone as bitting the flame bait will wield you nothing but a ENORMOUS headache... -__-
He or she has just been reported.
Bismarck.Eburo
Server: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1377
By Bismarck.Eburo 2011-08-31 11:14:47
I know nothing of how coding or any related stuff works.
Shiny graphics would be cool, but lol obviously that's never gonna happen, that's for FFXIV.
I also think that the main issue is money...BUT if ps2 support is responsible partly or entirely for the lack of additions to the game, then please throw it down the gutter.
Frankly I think they need to make the game less CPU intensive, even EVE Online (video card rapist) runs better than FFXI. ESPECIALLY while running two instances of Windower.
Fenrir.Mariane
Server: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1766
By Fenrir.Mariane 2011-08-31 11:18:04
You went on a huge rant about how the PS2 is awesome, and then told people to be honest.
It's not hard to pull an implication from that. And in general you have a brusque holier than thou attitude to anyone who disagrees with your point of view. The PS2 is awesome but it is old. I can't argue with that.
If the PS2 must be dropped it will be dropped. Me ranting won't change anything, will it ? I just like to hook my USA PS2 on a TV and be able to play with it in a couch lol.
If they drop the PS2 support means that PS3 will be dropped at the same time as it's playing on the PS3 as a PS2 game.
I have a PC with is capable of playing XIV so I'm not without FFXI if it gets dropped. I was even poking Sehachan at the test server yesterday ... /wave Sehachan
Whatever happens I'll accept (hahah like I have choice anyway) but come on no need to assume I'm attacking or anything. :\
Perhaps because you read some post of mine brawling with botter people in the past mean I'm a troll and a bad person ? -__-
I simply did steer away of such discussions as I noticed it just gives BAD KARMA.
I'd really like to know the percentages of the FFXI population that plays on the different platforms
So do I ... It would be interesting ...
Server: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 19647
By Valefor.Prothescar 2011-08-31 11:22:28
The PS2's RAM is an incredibly major bottleneck for FFXI. It's what keeps us capped at 80 inventory slots per bag, safe, etc. as the most prominent example.
The HDD isn't all used, but they can't use more than the partition given to them by Sony. Due to legal things that I once knew but forgot, something about the way the PS2's HDD is formatted to prevent piracy or something, Sony has to go and change the partition allocated to FFXI for SE to be able to take advantage of much more space than they've already used. HDD limitations is as much a valid issue as the horrible RAM.
This isn't about graphics, it's about basic game functions that are legitimately crippled by the PS2's lack of power and accessibility.
[+]
Quote: Starting today, we will be conducting a survey on the game client players use to play FINAL FANTASY XI.
How to answer the survey:
After you login to PlayOnline and select FINAL FANTASY XI under "Games", a survey will be displayed. Please place a check mark on the client you use to play FINAL FANTASY XI. (If you use multiple clients to play, please select all that are applicable.)
* This survey will be conducted on all PlayOnline accounts. Once the survey is answered, it will no longer be displayed.
Thank you for your understanding and cooperation!
Does this mean the end of the PS2 is finally nigh?!
|
|