Dougr said:
I find it amusing that someone in here claim that you're botting if you fish up only the manta and never the others. I do not bot and I never catch anything other than the Manta, It's all about knowing your fish and has nothing to do with botting.
Selective reading much? I said the same group of people would never, ever catch anything but manta. There are times when the manta will behave exactly like a Pugil making it damn near impossible to know what you have unless you release every Pugil-like mob(taking a chance at releasing the manta as well).
As for knowing your fish I have over 200 levels of Fishing across two characters and several mules so you may want to try a different argument.