Fourth Brunne Vs NQ SH

Not trying to start some heated debate...just wondering which would be better for tanking as NIN. I would think SH but the gear suggestion site suggests Brunne...and looking at it i can see because its only 1 less evasion and the addition of Subtle blow 7. Just wondering what everyone else's ideas are about it

Accuracy capped? Use Brunne.

Accuracy uncapped? Use SH.

Not meleeing? Between the two, use SH. This is the situation where you won't see a huge difference though, the HP lowers enmity loss ever so slightly and it's 1 more EVA.